After several NDR executives were relieved of their duties, the editors reacted to the scandal about alleged manipulations in reporting last night – in their programs.
The allegations against editorial managers at Norddeutscher Rundfunk (NDR) in Kiel have further personal consequences. The state radio station director Volker Thormählen takes a month’s unpaid leave. NDR Director General Joachim Knuth announced on Thursday that Thormählen had asked him on Wednesday evening “to gain some distance and to ensure, in the spirit of the NDR, that people who are not personally affected can be responsible for the clarification process”.
The director continued: “I thank him for this offer and I have accepted it. In the past few days it has become very clear to me that the state broadcasting center in Kiel not only needs to be clarified, but also that things need to be changed establish.
For days, more and more allegations against those responsible for editorial work in Kiel have come to light. The core question is whether these could have deliberately influenced the reporting by colleagues. There was also talk of a political filter.
In what is probably an unprecedented action, NDR television broadcast a protest by broadcaster employees in the “ Schleswig-Holstein Magazin ” on Wednesday evening.
Today’s episode is – and he speaks for all colleagues – “certainly one of the hardest,” explained Hanses. The fact that NDR executives are said to have manipulated the reporting “hits us to the core as independent journalists,” added his colleague Gabi Lüeße. Hanses continues: “Honestly, today we considered and discussed whether we wanted to and could produce a show at all. But honestly, we don’t want to duck away either. We also want to tell you what’s going on, because we simply know how benevolently you watch the show every night. “One remains loyal to NDR and public broadcasting, according to the moderators.
Moderator colleague Marie-Luise Bram also found similar words about the scandal in the news program “Schleswig-Holstein 18:00”. The editors found out about it themselves from the press, “and what we were able to read there stunned us,” says Bram.
Landesfunkhauschef Thormählen said on Thursday about his temporary vacation: “With this step, I would like to help ensure that the process I initiated can begin with the greatest possible participation of my colleagues and with external help and support, without giving the impression that I could influence it.” He came to this conclusion on Wednesday afternoon after an editorial conference. His deputy Bettina Freitag will take over the business until then.
There has been a rumbling in the public ARD house for days, employees are unsettled, there are crisis talks. NDR director Knuth said that Bettina Freitag would be provided with a team “that, together with her and her colleagues on site, will establish goal-oriented processes and structures that guarantee courageous, independent journalism.” This team will be assigned to a responsible person or report to a person responsible outside the state radio station.
It had already become known on Wednesday that the editor-in-chief at the Kiel site, Norbert Lorentzen, and the politician responsible for politics, Julia Stein, had asked them to be released from their previous duties until further notice. The presumption of innocence applies, as has been emphasized.
The starting point of the case were media reports: The online medium “Business Insider” and then “Stern” had written that there could be a kind of filter by the superiors in the editorial department. For example, it was about an interview that an NDR journalist wanted to conduct, but his superiors refused. Lorentzen and the NDR had rejected the allegation of political influence.
The independent state broadcasting council of Schleswig-Holstein has initiated an examination. In a letter to the state broadcasting director, NDR employees demanded complete clarification. It’s about the reputation of the station.
In the meantime, further allegations came up through a “Stern” report. Accordingly, Stein is said to have worked towards the German Red Cross (DRK) getting to see research documents for a contribution about a home in the north in the post-war years that was still planned at the time. Children are said to have been harassed in the facility. The “Stern” reports that the broadcasting company is said to have worked towards the research being at least weakened. In a post that was broadcast later, the DRK is said not to have been named as the person responsible for the home.
In this context, the “Stern” also reported on a private connection. The head of the DRK Schleswig-Holstein is said to have been in a relationship with the then state broadcasting council chairwoman of the NDR in Schleswig-Holstein at the time. She is currently no longer at the head of the committee. The independent state broadcasting council controls the program work in the ARD station. In addition, the “Stern” article went into the representative of the head of politics Stein and reported on photos in which the journalist was seen with his husband – a politician – in the middle of his election campaign for a mayoral office.
The director of the Landesfunkhaus Schleswig-Holstein added: “For the sake of good order, I would like to remind you that the presumption of innocence applies.”
The grievances in the public service broadcasting houses are obvious: a reform of the public service is needed. Nevertheless, we should not do without the public service system.
