Waco Shootout Aftermath: A Decade of Legal Drama
Ten years have passed since the deadly shootout between rival motorcycle clubs at a Twin Peaks restaurant in Waco that resulted in the deaths of nine individuals. Despite over 100 arrests made in connection with the incident, no one has been convicted to this day.
Indictments and Legal Battles
Following the May 2015 Twin Peaks shootout, a total of 155 people were indicted, leading to a wave of legal battles as lawyers from across the state took on clients involved in the case. Many of those arrested filed civil suits against the city of Waco and District Attorney Abel Reyna, primarily for wrongful arrest. These suits were put on hold pending trials or case dismissals.
Conflict of Interest Allegations
Lawyers representing some defendants in the Twin Peaks cases filed motions to disqualify Reyna as the prosecutor, alleging a conflict of interest. In response, Reyna denied any conflicts in prosecuting the cases but recused himself from four of them. Special prosecutor Brian Roberts was brought in to handle these cases, marking the first time an outside prosecutor reviewed any of the cases in McLennan County.
Challenges in Prosecution
Roberts described the cases as a “colossal mess” after reviewing the evidence and expressed doubts about the validity of the arrests. Only one of the 155 indicted individuals, Christopher “Jake” Carrizal, made it to trial. Carrizal’s trial in 2017 included weeks of testimony, including his own, where he claimed self-defense in the shooting incident.
Legal Complexities and Mistrials
During the trial, it was revealed that at least four of the nine deceased individuals were shot by police, leading to a grand jury clearing the officers of wrongdoing in 2016. The Carrizal trial faced numerous delays due to new evidence introductions, ultimately resulting in a mistrial when the jury couldn’t reach a unanimous decision.
Charges Dropped and Reindictments
In 2018, Roberts dropped the charges against the four defendants he was handling, citing insufficient evidence for prosecution. Reyna, on the other hand, dropped the remaining Engaging in Organized Crime charges and reindicted 25 people on charges of murder, rioting, and tampering with evidence, including Carrizal for rioting.
Election Fallout and Case Dismissals
Reyna lost his re-election bid for the District Attorney’s office, with Barry Johnson taking over in 2019. Johnson used the lack of criminal accountability in the Twin Peaks cases as a campaign strategy and eventually dropped all remaining charges due to a lack of evidence for pursuing murder charges. Civil suits against the city, county, police officers, and Reyna continue to be active, with many alleging civil rights violations.
Personal Stories of Loss and Legal Battles
One of the plaintiffs, Morgan English, shared her experience of being arrested at Twin Peaks with her husband and spending two weeks in jail. She filed a civil suit against the city, claiming false information in the arrest affidavit and seeking accountability for the lives affected that day. Despite moving on with her life, English still bears emotional scars from the incident, expressing fear in public spaces due to the trauma.
Restaurant Closure and Future Plans
Following the shootout, the Twin Peaks restaurant closed, with subsequent attempts to occupy the space proving unsuccessful. The latest owners expressed plans to open a Mexican-Cajun restaurant in the location, highlighting the ongoing impact of the tragic event on the community.
Support Independent Journalism
If you found the reporting above valuable, consider making a donation to support it. Your contribution helps fund the work on texasstandard.org and KWBU.org. Thank you for supporting independent journalism.
