https://cdnimg.rg.ru/img/content/193/57/36/iStock-1157444912_d_850.jpg

Absurd lawsuit home veterans by tenant continues for several years. And every year became more and more absurd. “RG” repeatedly wrote about this conflict. In 2017, it would seem that it was the point: the appellate court (the Novosibirsk regional court) laid everything on the shelves and confirmed the right of the recipient of social services to pay only for what they need. That is a specific example – if Alexander Zhukov is in the veterans home uses only the living room and Barber shop, it can’t be forced to pay for meals in the dining room (where he goes) and other “joys of life” in a government institution like Ironing.

This decision has entered into force, however, was not convinced by either the administration of the house of veterans, nor the regional Ministry of labour and social development. Here refer to the order of the regional Minister Yaroslav Frolov. This document States that in the hospital, the elderly have not a lot of different services, as a single complex, which can not be split.

That is, simply put, you can not go to the dining room and to the infirmary and to pay for it – be helpful. The cost of services for all of our guests are different. Because it is calculated from the amount of the pension each tenant -75 percent give. Here’s the entire complex.

the Fact that it is at least strange, in private conversations with “RG” has recognized the employees of the different law enforcement agencies. But the official reaction to this method of charging is not so far. And, obviously, will not: therefore, normal that never worked, the disabled person pays for a “complex” one amount, and fought in the hot spots military retiree – a very different, and much more.

Feeding in March this year, another lawsuit to Zhukov, the house veterans had no information about his pension. So I counted the invalid debt from March 2017 to June 2020 in 527 882 ruble 48 kopecks – the alleged “actual expenses.”

to find out how many bugs gets from the state, restrain your appetite – 75 percent of his pension for three years is only 186 thousand rubles. But, the court required the plaintiffs one: list of beetles actually rendered services and their cost. Such a document in a veterans ‘ home for several months and has not appeared. And no wonder.

But the welfare was provided to the court in another interesting paper. About the services, which allegedly received beetles. But about the prices on them there is nothing. But lists spending on the maintenance of the house veterans from the budget and extra-budgetary income. The salary of staff: 37 million for the six months 2020. The purchase of inventory 11 million. Utilities: almost three million. Total cost of 56 million odd, divide it by 400 guests, get 20 thousand in a month each. Now, apparently, this boiler and must to contribute to the poor bugs. To help you, so to speak, the state to contain welfare.

And what of the law? And the law says something quite different. To pay the inhabitants of the almshouse should be only for those services it actually received. According to certain rates. And this fee should not exceed 75 percent of his income. Feel the difference?

the Salaries of the staff nothing to do with it. And most importantly, as stated in the court decision, the law gives the recipient of social services to opt out of receiving them – paragraph 4 of article 9 of Federal law No. 442 “About the bases of social servicing of citizens in the Russian Federation” (legislative act called specifically for the regional Ministry of labour and social development as well as administration of the house of veterans). So no debt for allegedly exhibited for him in the dining room to dine with Alexander Zhukov, a long time ago, wrote a rejection of power, no.

the Court found that the beetles legitimately lives in the house of veterans on the basis of the agreement concluded in 2013, and pays for accommodation and cutting the tariffs 2011. And it is impossible for it to evict (such attempts have been served a lawsuit).

I Must say that the example of Zhukov to veterans home would be followed by many, but, alas, they have not yet obtained. Not enough strength to fight. Zhukov, not afraid of pressure and not to sign contracts with imposed services – and the majority of tenants is not able to. In addition, it is well suited to the protection of their rights, find a lawyer Arslan Egorov, who takes with him a reasonable fee.

But the bugs their “special” position is not proud – on the contrary, believes that there will come a time when the elderly will not have to fight for their penny with the house of veterans. Everything will be transparent and according to law.

Previous articleJoe found the “first”
Next articleIn Armenia was held a quiz “I learn Russian”
Jennifer Alvarez is an investigative journalist and is a correspondent for European Union. She is based in Zurich in Switzerland and her field of work include covering human rights violations which take place in the various countries in and outside Europe. She also reports about the political situation in European Union. She has worked with some reputed companies in Europe and is currently contributing to USA News as a freelance journalist. As someone who has a Masters’ degree in Human Rights she also delivers lectures on Intercultural Management to students of Human Rights. She is also an authority on the Arab world politics and their diversity.